November 18, 2026
This week's Docket leads with a ruling that the Bureau of Prisons needs court permission before it ends its union contract again. It also covers the December 11 funding deadline and the pay raise, a House bill to block OPM's nondisclosure agreements, early uses of last week's D.C. Circuit decision on removals, new union plaintiffs in a Schedule Policy/Career challenge, the MSPB's first ruling under the new probationary rule, and several more developments.
Court Tells BOP It Needs Permission Before Ending the AFGE Contract Again
The Bureau of Prisons may not end its contract with the National Council of Prison Locals, AFGE, unless the court allows it. On November 10 the federal district court in Connecticut ruled on BOP’s request to clarify the September 29 preliminary injunction that restored the agreement. BOP asked whether the injunction permits it to terminate the agreement again based on a new agency decision.
The court said it does, on one condition. The injunction rested on the facts before the court, including the BOP Director’s statements that the union was not the “kind of union” he supports. Other grounds for ending the agreement could satisfy the Administrative Procedure Act. BOP cannot act on its own. It must file a motion to modify or dissolve the injunction, and the court must grant it. The court declined to expedite that request.
Until then the agreement remains in effect through its May 28, 2029 expiration. The court voided BOP’s October 7 re-termination as improper self-help.
The Department of Veterans Affairs tried the same step in August in AFGE Local 2305 v. Department of Veterans Affairs. The district court there enforced its injunction, and the First Circuit has stayed that enforcement order pending appeal.
Funding Deadline Approaches With the 2027 Pay Raise Unresolved
Congress has until December 11 to fund the government, and a 2027 pay raise for most federal employees depends on what that legislation includes. Without action by Congress, the President’s pay freeze on General Schedule base and locality pay takes effect in January.
The administration is moving ahead with raises for one group, though. In a November 6 memo, OPM described its plan to give law enforcement personnel a 3.8 percent increase through special salary rates, Federal News Network reports. Positions newly added to the special rates could receive about 6.7 percent, which includes a catch-up adjustment.
Federal employee unions and their allies in Congress are pressing for a civilian raise in the funding bill. AFGE has called for at least 3.8 percent, matching the law enforcement figure. The FAIR Act, sponsored by Rep. James Walkinshaw and Sen. Brian Schatz, would provide 4.1 percent.
Government Executive reports that Democrats and employee groups are also expected to seek measures reversing the executive orders that excluded agencies from the Statute. Senate Democrats are weighing how to use the deadline in negotiations. A lapse in appropriations would begin December 12.
House Bill Would Block OPM’s Governmentwide Nondisclosure Agreement
Two House members introduced a bill last week to stop OPM from finalizing its proposed nondisclosure agreements for federal employees. The No Disrupting Accountability Act, H.R. 11019, sponsored by Reps. Raja Krishnamoorthi (D-Ill.) and Greg Landsman (D-Ohio), would bar the use of federal funds to develop, finalize, implement, or enforce the agreements, Federal News Network reports.
OPM published the draft agreement on May 27. It is a standard form for agencies that choose to use it, for both new and current employees. Signers would agree not to disclose “confidential government information,” which the notice defines to include nonpublic material on internal agency operations and personnel matters. OPM says the form documents existing obligations and does not override whistleblower protections. The proposal drew nearly 32,000 comments. OPM has not finalized it.
The form connects to a rule already in effect. OPM’s suitability rule, effective July 30, lists refusal to certify compliance with nondisclosure obligations as a ground for a suitability action. AFSCME, NFFE, and NTEU support the bill. Government Executive reports that it is expected to be among the demands in the year-end funding talks.
Plaintiffs Put the Abramowitz Decision to Work in Removal Cases
Within three days of the D.C. Circuit’s November 10 decision in Abramowitz v. Lake, plaintiffs in two pending cases asked district courts to apply it. Three career Department of Justice employees filed the decision on November 12 in Gordon v. Executive Office of the President, where a motion to dismiss has been fully briefed since January. The Government Accountability Project and NARFE filed it on November 13 in their challenge to Schedule Policy/Career.
In both cases the government argues that the Civil Service Reform Act sends the claims to the Merit Systems Protection Board. Abramowitz rejected that argument for a removal claim, and the court said it was wary of “overreading the CSRA’s preclusive scope.” The decision rested on a statute specific to Voice of America, so district courts will decide how far its reasoning reaches.
Other removal cases also moved.
The government answered the complaint in Marrazzo v. Kennedy on November 16, and the docket shows no appeal. Elizabeth Oyer’s opposition to the motion to dismiss in Oyer v. Blanche is now due November 24. Mary Comans asked the Fourth Circuit on November 16 to suspend briefing until it rules on her motion to dismiss the government’s appeal.
AFGE, AFSCME, and the AFL-CIO Join a Challenge to Schedule Policy/Career
AFGE, AFSCME, the AFL-CIO, and AFGE Local 1923 are now plaintiffs in PEER v. Trump, the challenge to Executive Order 14171 pending in federal district court in Maryland. On October 16 the court granted Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER) leave to file a second amended complaint adding the unions, and denied the government’s pending motion to dismiss. On November 4 the court extended the government’s deadline to respond to January 5, 2027.
AFGE and AFSCME dismissed their own suit in November 2025 and said they would pursue their claims in this case. The amended complaint completes that move.
Two other challenges are further along. In NTEU’s suit, the government moved to dismiss on October 7. In the Government Accountability Project and NARFE case, the motion to dismiss has been fully briefed since November 6. No court has enjoined Schedule Policy/Career, and agencies continue to move positions into it while the cases proceed.
MSPB: A Probationary Appointment Ends Automatically Without Agency Certification
A probationary or trial-period employee whose agency does not certify them for retention loses the job automatically, and the Merit Systems Protection Board will not hear the appeal. The Board so held on October 22 in Laboy v. Department of Homeland Security, 2026 MSPB 10, its first precedential decision applying Civil Service Rule XI.
Executive Order 14284 created the rule. Under it, the appointment ends at the close of its last day unless the agency certifies, within the 30 days before, that keeping the employee advances the public interest. DHS made no certification. It emailed the employee a termination notice the afternoon after his two-year trial period ended. An administrative judge held that he had completed two years and gained appeal rights. The Board reopened the case on its own and reversed. It held that the appointment had already expired, so he never became an “employee,” and that the late notice did not change the result.
The Board also held that it cannot decide whether the rule violates the Administrative Procedure Act. That challenge belongs in federal court. Employees near the end of a probationary period should not assume that working past the anniversary date secures their status.
Other Developments
Intelligence officers. The Fourth Circuit issued its mandate on November 12 in Doe 1 v. ODNI, putting its July decision for the terminated intelligence officers into effect. A petition for Supreme Court review would be due by February 1, 2027.
NFFE v. USDA. The court ruled on November 13 that USDA need not produce the administrative record in NFFE’s challenge to the Secretary of Agriculture’s religious messages to the workforce. The court cited its tentative ruling dismissing the Administrative Procedure Act claims. The injunction and dismissal motions remain under submission.
Voice of America. The government replied on November 16 that the vacatur claims in Widakuswara v. Lake and Abramowitz v. Lake are moot because a 2026 program plan has replaced the March 2025 decisions. It says the agency has returned 168 employees to work. The mootness question is now fully briefed.
FEMA claims. The parties in AFGE v. Trump held a further settlement conference on November 12 and will hold another on December 3. The court moved the joint statement on relief and the fee application to December 4.
USDA relocations. The order blocking relocations in AFGE v. USDA remains in effect while the government’s Ninth Circuit appeal proceeds. No stipulated clarification of the order appears on the district court docket.
GAO. The President has nominated OMB Deputy Director Eric Ueland to lead the Government Accountability Office for a 15-year term, Government Executive reports. A Senate committee hearing is set for November 19. GAO issued last week’s report on USDA’s reorganization planning.
SSA schedules. The Social Security Administration’s announced end date for all alternative work schedules was November 16. AFGE has filed a grievance.
Take the Public Service Viewpoint Survey by December 4
The Partnership for Public Service is running its Public Service Viewpoint Survey for a second year, and current federal employees have until 11:59 p.m. EST on December 4 to take it. The survey is open to permanent, civilian, career employees. It takes about 10 minutes, and the Partnership asks that employees complete it outside working hours.
The Partnership began the survey after OPM did not administer the Federal Employee Viewpoint Survey in 2025. OPM has since replaced that survey with a shorter one that each agency runs on its own, and agencies have until December 31 to send it out. The Partnership’s survey is meant to give Congress and the public an independent, governmentwide view of the federal employee experience.
Responses are confidential. The Partnership no longer asks for a personal email address, and it does not release results for any group with fewer than 30 respondents. We encourage every eligible federal employee to take part.
Dates We’re Watching
November 19: Status conference on discovery in the challenge to Executive Order 14251, AFGE v. Trump, No. 3:25-cv-03070 (N.D. Cal.).
November 20: Unions’ response to the government’s motion to dismiss in AFGE v. Trump, No. 3:25-cv-03070 (N.D. Cal.).
November 20: Maurene Comey’s response on her First Amendment claim in Comey v. Department of Justice. The government’s response is due December 1.
November 23: VA’s opening brief in the First Circuit appeal of AFGE Local 2305 v. Department of Veterans Affairs.
November 23: Government’s dispositive motion in NTEU’s challenge to the IRS advanced leave directive, NTEU v. IRS, No. 1:26-cv-02938 (D.D.C.).
November 24: Elizabeth Oyer’s opposition to the motion to dismiss in Oyer v. Blanche.
Follow these and other cases on the Rise Up Litigation Tracker, which is updated weekly and available to search or download as a PDF or spreadsheet.
In Solidarity,
Suzanne Summerlin
General Counsel
Rise Up: Federal Workers Legal Defense Network